The whole point of a betting exchange such as Betfair is to provide an environment to bet in which is redundant of a bookmaker. All your bets are matched against other punters to remove the middle man and a small commission is paid on all winning bets. In theory it shouldn’t matter if you win or lose money as a punter because it has no effect on the company providing the service. Unfortunately it appears this isn’t case. I was talking to my friend Dave, who runs a detailed portal about betting sites and he let me in on a few things about BetUnFair.
In 2008 Betfair, who are the biggest betting exchange in the world, introduced a whopping 20% commission for consistent winners. Given that the starting commission paid is only 5% on any winning bet this shook things up considerably and now Betfair have decided, as of July 18th 2011, that commissions will be rising to between 40% and 60% for those that have lifetime profits over £250,000.
Whilst the figure of £250,000 might not seem like a lot who’s to say that over the next few years they won’t just periodically decrease this figure. At present BetUnFair claim that the new hike in commissions will only affect around 500 users. However anyone with over £250k in profit is likely not only providing a lot of liquidity on the exchanges but also making a living from trading sports as well. That’s 500 people out of a job right there, well that’s after they break £250k in their wives, brothers, mothers, sisters and cousins accounts.
It doesn’t matter how long you’ve been using Betfair either. If your account is positive £250k or more then you’re paying the new increased fees. This seems particularly unfair on the punter that’s been using Befair for 10 years and making a consistent profit of around £25,000 per year.
Winning punters on Betfair are often thought to be those using software programs to trade very small margins during in play markets. Whilst these particular punters do provide little value to both other punters using Betfair and Betfair themselves the fact remains that in the group of 500 there will be a percentage who are relying on their individual knowledge or systems to profit. If what Betfair are trying to do with this move is weed out the robots then surely there’s better ways to do this than the proposed increase in commissions.
What this all really means is that Betfair are attempting to discourage winning punters from using the exchanges. In recent years they’ve already introduced a section of their website where you bet against Betfair as opposed to other punters and it looks more and more like they’re headed towards becoming an online bookmaker as opposed to a betting exchange.
From a company that once promised ‘Winners are always welcome’ the above changes come as a reel kick in the teeth. Befair really do need to decide if they are a betting exchange or a regular bookmaker.
If someone would provide a viable alternative to Betfair then maybe things would be different but until their monopoly is dissolved if we want to play we play by their rules. With less and less value to be had at Betfair I suggest you check out Dave’s site where he lists other sites good for football betting.
In case you missed it
Betfair has also managed to F-over winning casino players as well. You can read about this in the Online Poker Sites Betfair Warning. The short gist they claimed casino players who won in their generous bonus offer were “violating the spirit of the bonus”. These uses didn’t do a thing wrong. The spirit of gambling is the beat the house. Gamblers play all day long in games they have little long term chance to win, Betfair has made hundreds of millions of dollars from gamblers wagering –EV games, and the one time bettors win on a mass scale (due to BetUnFair’s error) rather than suck it up they flat out stole the money back.
Mu$on telling it to you like it is. I still play at Betfair. We still promote them on some of our portals, the changes and theft affected a small number of people… however who knows how things play out long term. At this point be cautious when betting with this company and consider other options such as Bookmaker, Pinnacle, Bodog and the likes where it is still possible to “Bet Fair” (pun intended). Okay I’m tired now as this was a long post. Mu$on must beat up on some more fish so I can have money to get my pimp on come Friday. Best of luck to all my degen readers, Mu$on here signing out.
